Baked Goods, Sweets & Treats

The Candy Cottage is a locally-owned confectionery. We specialize in unique holiday treats, custom favors for any occasion, baskets, corporate gifts, chocolate boxes and more. We also carry candy making… Continue Reading Candy Cottage

Charlie’s Cookies specializes in Monster and Chocolate Chip cookies in memory of Charles Walters – who could never turn down a cookie… or two! This home cottage production also operates… Continue Reading Charlie’s Cookies

Cocco’s Cookies is a home bakery out of Pataskala, OH, specializing in large, quarter pound cookies. Choose from a large selection of delicious flavors, with new varieties always on the… Continue Reading Cocco’s Cookies

Elizabeth’s Originals is grounded in the belief that delicious and healthy can be one and the same. All of the foods share a blend of natural and locally sourced ingredients… Continue Reading Elizabeth’s Originals

I am a cottage food operation and a follower of Jesus! Ran right out of my country kitchen your source for local made from scratch treats! I make several varieties… Continue Reading Faithfully Sweet Treats

Great Harvest has been baking bread the way it ought to be from the beginning, and we still believe in our phenomenal bread-making process. We still believe in using pure,… Continue Reading Great Harvest Bread

Hammerie Farm offers a wide range of products including seasonal produce, lettuce, preserves using our fruit, baked goods, and body care products. We use sustainable practices in all aspects of… Continue Reading Hammerie Farm

Homeplace Bakery is a home bakery that offers the freshest, most delicious pies money can buy. We have no brick and mortar location and sell our pies through the Lancaster… Continue Reading Homeplace Bakery

Knollwood Cakes makes custom homemade cakes and cupcakes. I strive to make each cake not only delicious, but also as cute and creative as possible. I work hard to make… Continue Reading Knollwood Cakes

Annette freshly grinds the flour for her wholesome, homemade baked goods! Start your weekend with cinnamon rolls, power through the morning with handmade protein bars and plan for dinner with… Continue Reading Koinonia Farms

Our story began in the fall of 2020 with our family, the Dolce’s. We love granola and decided to try our hand at making it. Many recipes and pounds of… Continue Reading La Dolce ‘Nola

Specializing in fresh popped kettle corn. Over 20 flavors! Made to order for us events, parties, and fundraisers.

I am a home-maker who loves to bake, and provide delicous baked goods with no preservatives or soy ingredients. My best sellers are cinnamon rolls and sourdough bread, both of… Continue Reading Miller’s Home Baking

We are Nick & Susie. We sell our baked goods and artisan jam at the farmers market May to October in Lancaster, Ohio. Our products are also available inside Keller… Continue Reading New Roots Farm

Pure maple syrup used in everything we make, for a healthier lifestyle. We sell pantry staples, baked goods and more.

Square 7 Coffee House, a downtown Lancaster staple for 9 years, is located inside the Art & Clay on Main studios. Exclusively serving custom roasted beans from central Ohio’s own… Continue Reading Square 7 Coffee House

Sweet Space Bakery is a home bakery specializing in gourmet caramels and brittles. Caramel flavors include original, sea salt, and the seasonally available apple cider. Brittles are available in original… Continue Reading Sweet Space Bakery

The Carpenter Farm Project is a family-run homestead striving to get back to the root of where food should come from. Starting with farm fresh chickens and eggs, humanely raised… Continue Reading The Carpenter Farm Project

Fry Pies are a flaky pastry filled with fresh fruit filling and then deep fried and dipped into a creamy glaze.

Gourmet truffles, caramels & candy bars. Organic & regionally sourced ingredients. No retail shop. Visit Keller Market in Lancaster for delicious selections! Wren Valley Truffles is a shining gem located… Continue Reading Wren Valley Truffles